Sunday, 8 December 2013

Chapter 4


*Materials will be in Chapter 3. But I finish this chapter first.

Chapter 4 Exterior Forms

Today, cities are filled with buildings that are competing to be the most eye-catching structure. The mindset of great buildings symbolizes the growing success of the country was one of the factors for these dynamic buildings to continue developing, for instance, the commonly discussed topic was which country has the title for “The World’s Tallest Building”. Most importantly, exterior form is the most significant element besides colour and material for users to judge a building. Previously, it is easy to identify styles due to the established building form and similar design approach from architects of the same period such as the Bauhaus style; the form of modern contemporary on the contrary is rather hard to define (O’Gorman, 1998) due to the reason that minimalism form with geometrical lines or the conceptual architecture with dynamic structure are all considered as modern style. Nonetheless, the key point here is to examine the female user’s positive and negative perception towards these modern designs that is constantly transforming.
From previous chapter, some colour and material are easily categorize as feminine due to the majority of female preference towards it as well as the characteristic that is associated with female. On the other hand, form together with the combination of colour and material as well as its function may be difficult and debatable to distinguish between feminine and masculine building based on stereotype perception, Therefore, the intention is to focus on structural form only and the idea is expected to further assist in examining the research issue.

Architecture is a language of metaphor (O’Gorman,1998). Survey conducted by Menna Agha shows how people see gender qualities in the built environment.* The results indicate the general mindset of gendered architecture in people’s mind. On the whole, curve, organic and simple was defined as feminine form whereas geometrical, angle and complex being masculine form. (Agha, Taw, 2010) A survey was conducted to investigate how female response between the three chosen modern contemporary exterior forms with the scale of 1 as most unwelcoming to 5 as most welcoming. Hypotheses were made that older female as well as lower income and status respond more negatively towards modern geometrical forms.

*Refer to Appendix for details.

                             Fig.1 Linear form     Fig.2 Curvature form               Fig.3 Dynamic form


Fig. 4 Overall results. With the scale of 1 = most unwelcoming and 5 = most welcoming.

Based on the survey result conducted for this project, most female respond positively towards the curvature exterior form (Fig.2) in which majority picked the scale of 3, 4 and 5. Psychologists and neuroscientists have stated that human preference towards curves is mainly because it is hard-wired into the brain. (Jaffe, 2013)  Experts have also announced that rounded corner is easier for the eye. (Anthony, 2011)* Other factors could be the similarity of curvy forms to a woman’s physique that conveys the feminine idea of nurturing to female (Izhaki, 2013). Likewise, the fact that round organic shapes are well associated with nature emits warmth and harmony (Adams, 2013) In 1909, psychologist Kate Gordon said, “Curves are in general felt to be more beautiful than straight lines”. (Adams, 2013)

Fig.5 Seattle Central Library

On the other hand, the dynamic form (Fig. 3) consists of both positive and negative responses.  Angular design can either be attractive or provocative, depending on different users. For instance, the mix criticism towards the Seattle Central Library (Fig.5) by Rem Koolhaas in which some commented as “beautiful” and some “horrifying”. (Wirednewyork.com, 2003) Sharp angles subconsciously remind us of knife or claws that is harmful. (Nixon, 2010) Linear form (Fig. 1) received the most negative responses. Lines and symmetrical shapes portray the masculine attributes of starkness and formality induced lower preferences.











Fig.6 Responses from age below 20. Fig.7 Responses from age 21 – 30.










Fig.8 Responses from age 31 - 40. Fig.9 Responses from age 41 – 50.









Fig.10 Responses from age 51 - 60. Fig.11 Responses from age 61 and more.

From the results, age shows to be one of the fundamental factors that influence the responses. Young adults with age below 20 and 21 – 30 years old responded that dynamic exterior form is the most welcoming mainly because they are living in the future. In this world of technological advancement, the new generation lives in a world that is more volatile and complex than any previous time. Also, “The future is feminine, the feminine is more masculine” Young women are rejecting the traditional role and redefining their feminine role to be in tune with the changes of the future. (Business Future Network London, 1997) At the age of 31 – 40, working women are often exposed to the surrounding building, hence the respond were quite neutral for all three forms although that result was showing curvature and dynamic as the most welcoming. Positive responses for curves and linear increase and angular form decrease, as women get older. In fact, majority of women ages 61 and above react negatively towards the dynamic form. Older generation viewed linear shapes as typicality owing to the fact most of the everyday objects or buildings are designed in basic shapes (Bar & Neta, 2007), results in familiarity towards the exterior form. A few notable negative keywords for the angular form were recorded during a short conversation with several elderly such as “weird, shocking and sharp”. Other important factor for older age female to prefer sinuous is the traditional mindset for Feng Shui. Basically, older generation believes that angle or corner means abrupt stoppage and emits negative energies whereas curve or sphere symbolizes continuous flow, and therefore harmony and eternity. (Nick, 2003)










Fig.12 Lower education level. Fig.13 Middle education level.












Fig.14 Higher education level.

Factors like education level along with social status could also be the factors that influence the female perception towards the exterior form. Results show that female with lower education level respond negatively towards the dynamic and linear form. The high possibility that lower education lead to lack of confidence and exposure to different architecture structure seeing that the majority in this category (Fig.12) are female with age 61 and above with no income. In contrast, female with middle education level feel most comfortable towards dynamite form. At this level, the group (Fig.13) is likely to be or have been university or college students hence, they feel prefer trendy with the latest technology and high exposure towards the Internet. Eventually, higher education shows more positive responses towards all three forms, especially linear form compared to low and middle education level. Female in this group are mainly women with high-income status that are confident and have a more open-minded thinking.
In a nutshell, the exterior architecture gives the first impression that triggers the desire to enter a building. Female negative and positive responses for exterior form or facade are particularly important, as women are now also the equal primary users together with men. Although the hypothesis was achieved but due to the difficulties in finding the balance numbers for all age group in each education level which in some measure could affect the accuracy of the results. Nonetheless, female high preference for sinuous shapes compare to linear and dynamic form is important to taken into design consideration. Future studies could look into other factors such as period trends, fashion, culture and others. (Bar & Neta, 2005) Furthermore, the issue of imbalance gender in the field of architecture is also important to take note whereby the design approach between men and women has always been very different. Clearly, modern designs are moving more towards masculine traits in terms of functionality and aesthetic value. Marika Shioiri-Clark and John Cary noted in an article for CNN, “It is not a question of whether, but to what extent, buildings are less beautiful, less functional, less equitable because women are not creating them.” Architecture is becoming no longer just a shelter but artworks to be appreciated by people.  

*Slight changes on the last part. However, I'm still not confirm with it yet.

Thanks for reading.

Sunday, 1 December 2013

Chapter 2

Chapter 2.0 - Colour Preferences


          Colour is a powerful design element in the built environment. The styles and trends in the world of colour are constantly evolving. It is important to understand that the psychological perception of colour is subjective, and only general preferences and evaluation will be taken into account in this project.  Research has proof that colours can affect the moods, perception, behavior and even health.*(Daggett, 2008) While there are no fix category of what colours are feminine, masculine or gender neutral, numerous studies carried out shows that women tend to react more positively to a  red-based colour than men* (Hurlbert, 2007). In fact, there had always been a saying, girls like pink. Beyond pink and purple, pastel colours are well associated with women mostly due to its ‘feminine’ traits that portray women as gentle and fragile. (Reed, 2013) At the sametime, study has also found out women prefer tints more than shades, in other words, soft colours. (Radeloff 1990) There are differences in colour preference and perception based on gender (Ficek, 2000)(Fig. 1), women are more colour conscious and diverse in colour choices than men (Guilford and Smith,1959)(Fig. 2) which uphold the importance of consideration for both gender.


Fig. 1 Male and female colour preferences.


Fig. 2 Male and female perception on colours.

*Please see the Appendix for a summary of the theory, history, physiology, and psychology of color.


Fig. 3 Victorian colours.

Fig. 4 Exterior                           Fig. 5 Interior



Fig. 6 Evolution of colours in 1950 – 2005*                               


    Fig. 7 Key colours in 2010
       
*Please refer to Appendix for more information on the influence in the changing of colour scheme.

In the past, classical colour as seen in the Victorian scheme (Fig. 3) that was well associate with women appears to be more delicate or harmonious tones in a mixture of earthy and lighter shades (Abrams, 2001). During those times, home gives the feeling of simple and comfortable (Fig. 4 & 5). Gradually, new technologies (fax machines, modems) causes black, grey and white colour to became popular (Fig. 6). At the end of 1990s, minimalism became an obsession along with neutral and natural-inspired colours (Fig. 7) (Resene, 2012). Currently, modern and contemporary colour schemes are more towards monochromatic and sophisticated style. However, bold and vibrant colours are commonly used as accent to complement with natural colours such as light brown and soft grey. Overall, the modern built environment no longer appears soft but rather showing a strong and straightforward individuality. The toughness, simplicity and dominance traits found in modern style closely portray the masculine attribute. (Reed, 2013)

After seeing the significant differences of colour preference between genders, six interiors with different colour palettes were used to record their preferences. Hypothesis was made that women feel unpleasant in the bold dark colour scheme.
Fig.8 Cool hues of pink and white, low contrast                       Fig.9 Cool hues of black and white, high contrast   

Fig.10 Warm hues of red, black and white, high contrast   Fig.11 Neutral hues of turquoise and pink, medium contrast  
Fig.12 Warm hues of green and yellow, high contrast         Fig.13 Neutral hues of light brown and white, low contrast


Fig.14 Age below 20 colour preferences                Fig.15 Age 21-30 colour preferences


Fig.16 Age 31-40 colour preferences                     Fig.17 Age 41-50 colour preferences


Fig.18 Age 51-60 colour preferences                     Fig.19 Age 61 and more colour preferences

Compare to popular soft bedroom colours during 90s (Fig. 20) (Romano, 2011), younger individuals from age below 20 nowadays enjoy more vibrant and stimulating colours (Fig. 14). Modern visual media such as cartoons and games that uses strong colour contrast could be one of the factors that influence the responses.

 Fig.20 Bedroom in TV series “Sister, Sister”   


Fig.21 Room deco online games

         Surprisingly, the survey results (Fig.15) show that in a private home interior space females ages 21-30 prefer a brighter and softer tone (Fig.8) eventhough studies shows that black is the dominant product colour choice for young adults (Akcay, 2012) and the fact that they enjoy hanging out at a dark cool environment places. One of the primary factor is the established mindset of gender stereotyping colour preference at this age could influence the selection for soft feminine colour as they begin to identify the meaning of colours. In addition, this age group has a broader range of colour preferences, owing to the fact they are more open and experimental with influences from peers and exposure to trends and the Internet. (Empower yourself colour psychology, 2013). Even so, this age group responded negatively towards the neutral colour palette (Fig.11). It is suggested that the mixture of colour combination creates confusion and distraction. Research shows that people at this age will be going through rapid emotional changes as well as the characteristic of moodiness (BBC, 2013), therefore, young adults prefer palette that emits positive vibe instead of negative emotion for their individual space as seen in the preference for Image A, C and E.
          Following that, one could say with maturity, older female preference towards brown increases and bright colours like yellow and green decreases. (also refer to Joe Hallock's polls on color preferences in Appendix) Women ages 31-40 that are often exposed to the male dominated working space was found to respond well in monochrome colour scheme which is stereotypically a masculine colour scheme. Reasons being black are often see as a colour of sophistication and confidence that could portray them as successful and capable as men. (empower-yourself-with-color-psychology.com, 2013)
           From the short conversation with older women, poor eyesight problem was found to be the main influence of the responses. Female ages 60 and above feel more comfortable in bright colour interior such as Image F, A and C. Other than that, the eagerness for warmth and peacefulness could draw them towards soft pastels that is emotionally supporting and mentally soothing. (Resene, 2013) For that reason, the colour preferences for elderly women differ significantly with the modern palette that consist of black and bold colours.

 Fig.22 Overall colour preferences.

       Overall, Image F (Fig.13) was the colour that most age group feels comfortable. The beige and white hues proofs that most women prefer a mixture balance of warm and cool tones.  Also, the shade of natural colour always denotes security and harmony. Based on the results, female preference for a softer and feminine palette such as Image A and F was relatively high. This shows that though women becomes more independent along with the acceptance of modern colour scheme, softer shades of red and brown are still the leading selection colour for private spaces like interior home where they can exemplify their womanly traits.  Majority feels negatively towards bold and dark colours (Image B, C and D). Consequently, the hypothesis for this project was proven.

Chapter 1


*I haven't update the picture referencing yet.

1.0 History and Gender Qualities: Gender Differences in the Build Environment
 “Women have a unique perspective on the world, and it is not to say that men cannot design excellent cities, or a good nursery or workplace, but everybody would benefit from designs by both halves of the gene pool.” – Christine Murray (editor of the Architects' Journal)

    Gender can be categorized into “feminine” and “masculine” or “androgynous”, in other words, neutral. Stereotypically, feminine traits is commonly describe as emotional, soft, nurturing whereas masculine is aggressive, independent and non-emotional. Although architecture may sometimes be viewed as masculine or feminine through defining the architecture elements, forms and styles but it is important to point out that does not necessary link to a designer's gender. For instance, Oscar Niemeyer was famous for his use of abstract forms and curves. Even so, in the field of architecture which is male dominated, it was mentioned that women designer’s approach towards the built environment is unlike men (Fig. 1). Margaret I. Kennedy also provided some architecture design works from both female and male to prove differences between an environment shaped by man and an environment shaped by woman (Fig. 2) (Kennedy, 1981) In addition, Christine Murray, editor of Architect’s Journal said that “more women architects could lead to better designed cities that were more “humane”, “safer” and “liveable”. (Hough, 2013) It had been assumed how a female-formed city with less masculine would be like, “Not tall, for a start. One imagines a city of maybe six or eight storeys, perhaps quite dense but crazed with interconnecting laneways and gardens and courtyards, lots of shared spaces, public transport, trees and street furniture. A city of quiet orderliness, more focused on the spaces and relationships between things, than the things themselves.”(Farrelly, 2011) Still, the point here is neither to claim that woman is a better designer nor architecture should favor towards one-sided dominance but rather focusing on the feminine attributes of women and how a welcoming and comfortable place would look like for women. In general, women want to be in a place where they feel safe and comfortable. Therefore, how do women feel about the modern built environment?

 Fig 1 A comparison between “female” principles and “male” principles. (Kennedy, 1981)


Fig. 2 Typical design by man (A) and woman (B). Structure by man tend to be more linear and focus on height to grab attention whereas design approach by woman is more circular and in human scale.



Fig. 3 Case Mila by Gaudi and the exterior and interior of Victorian style that shows feminine qualities.

          The idea of feminism qualities in architecture and design has evolved throughout the years. Historically, Vitruvius have associated the ornamented surface with femininity, not masculinity” (Sanders 1996, 77). The Rococo or Art Nouveau architecture was often viewed as feminine with the elaborate ornamentation as well as the fanciful forms. (Fig. 3) Eventually, the Victorian Queens Anne style started a new image of femininity in which domesticity as well as women role as wife and mother play an important aspect when designing the built environment. This had lead to the idea of a cozy space with soft colours and delicate accessories as a typical feminine stereotype image. Feminine space is expressive, playful, sensual and harmony, the curve structure used often resembles the women body (Fig 4). It offers a different kind of experience compared to a masculine space; it engages emotion and awakens the imagination – a realm for heart and soul. (Mejia, 2013) Gaetano Pesce, an Italian architect commented on huge masculine structures, “Had the project been done with feminine values,” he said, “it would have been more human, more sensual, more joyous.”



Fig. 4. Architecture and interior design with prominent feminine qualities.

             Nevertheless, the perception towards the built environment has changed tremendously in the modern age. Modernist such as Louis Sullivan quoted: “feminine qualities are inappropriate to public buildings.” Under the influence of these famous architects along with the idea of mass production, logical design, and function over style leads to the machine age of refine and simplify design. Increasingly, the gender categorization between spaces are becoming more blurred due to evolution of modern contemporary design. Modern built environment consists of plain walls, angular clean lines, minimal accessories and bare finishes that basically reflects the masculine qualities. Marjory Mejia, a female writer wrote, “I yearned for a different kind of space, a different kind of flow, a different kind of sacredness. I didn’t find it in the churches that dominated the land, I found it in the wild gardens of my home and imagination, in the realm of the feminine.” Although most of the space does maintain neutrality in the design to promote equality between males and females, but the sensuous softness of feminine has gradually disappear. (Fig. 5) Following that, some female spaces had started to withdraw from feminine attributes and adopt the masculine side either to appear equal with men or for the sake of following the modern trend. (Fig. 6)


Fig. 5 Modern public spaces that reflects masculine qualities.



Fig. 6 Modern retail shops (Chanel and Victoria Secret) that sell female products.

          “Beauty is in the eye of the beholder”, not to mention that it is women’s nature to have changeable minds. (AlFin, 2009) Needless to say that there are in fact many other factors that influence the female feelings towards the built environment. Focusing on the contemporary condition and changing definition of gender in architecture, designers and architects should be mindful of the female opinions through understanding the factors that influenced them in which will be discussed in the following chapters.

Sunday, 3 November 2013

Introduction


In general, we live in a gender sensitive world of male and female, with different preferences and opinions. Similarly, architecture can also be categorized into neutral or be divided into female or male. Female is regard as feminine while male is masculine. Feminine architecture is rather unfamiliar compared to masculine architecture seeing that the built environment is mainly male dominated. Nonetheless, most people could not accept either a total feminine or masculine design. Balance would be a better choice in today’s built environment. Still, modern architecture and design are reduced to its simplest form, closely embracing to the dictum “less is more masculine”. The current built environment has an obvious dominating masculine factor, therefore, do women feel comfortable and welcome in this mannish surrounding which is contrary to their feminine identity?

        In the past, men have the supremacy to control and design their surrounding space. Most of the time, the public spaces are designed for men. During those days, women are assumed to stay at home undertaking domestic responsibilities around the house. Home interior seems to be the only few spaces for the female to exemplify their womanly persona as seen in the Victorian Queen Anne style interiors, elaborate floral patterns and myriad of decorative elements. The nineteenth century middle class style marks the beginning of the stereotype image of feminism qualities in interior. From that point of view, women’s idea of a comfortable living environment is noticeable through the prominent feminine attributes.

         In addition, Margaret I. Kennedy stated in an article that there are differences in design approaches between men and women. Studies from psychology and neuroscience shows on average, women design according to function follow form and men vice versa, thus, women's design are often more ergonomic and user friendly than men which tend to be monumental and design oriented. Women are known as altruistic and emotional being, therefore, feminine built environment always transmit a homelike and hospitable traits in which modern masculine design usually lack of. In the past, female opinions are often neglected due to the absence of women involvement in the design process. Today, women are equal to men yet throughout the years, the mentality of women itself and the definition of modern feminism has changed. As a result, female preferences and perception are different from before. Even so, the consideration of a women’s opinion in design is still thin on the ground despite the fact that female are becoming the primary users.

          However, the aim of this report is not to reinforce gender prejudice but merely surveying the root of the problem as to how women respond in the modern built environment that is gradually transforming towards a more masculine design. Through this research, it intends for more consideration of feminine aspect in architecture design thorough understanding of the preferences and perception of female user, and also the factors which may influence their responses towards modern environment. Gender stereotyping items will be discussed to distinguish the characteristic of feminine and masculine. Two different aspects are taken into consideration in the research which is the modern building elements and individual backgrounds. Modern elements that will be examined include colours and materials, decorative accessories, lighting, circulation and forms. Modern architecture with dynamic and rigid features could affect female to response either positively or negatively.  Individual profiles such as age, education level, occupation, income and marital status is highly assumed to also influence the female perception of contemporary design. For instance, modern women who are independent may no longer like feminine elements but prefer to be in a masculine environment.

        Nonetheless, the findings may vary from other women or other research that has been done before due to the limited numbers of chosen participants and other circumstances. Opinion and judging are also subjective. However, with the collected results from the questionnaire, it is expected to give an adequate overview of the percentage of different females’ acceptance or rejection towards the modern built environment. The objective of the research is to understand how and why certain groups of female react positively or negatively in the modern built environment and let designers be more aware of the issue of female’s opinion in modern design. People often neglected the impact of the environment space had on female. This research and analysis will help designers focus and see more clearly of the crisis of architecture in the present day in order to rediscover and have a better grasp of ways to enhance the experience of female users.

      Women have raise their increasing concern regarding their environment through organizing various feminist discussions and movements. In whichever ways, examining this issue remains a positive approach that encourages designers to rethink the relationship between architecture and women. Architecture and the built environment sometimes unconsciously transmit information of how the society would perceive gender. A building is like a messenger to the next generation, hence, we must be careful of how we express and input the ideas. Perhaps this research that addressing a “women’s” concern in the first place, might turns out to be a possibility of change for everyone.

*********************************************************************************

Some quotes that I think could link with this topic:

“Women are the real architects of society.” - Cher


And when an architect has designed a house with large windows, which is a necessity today in order to pull the daylight into these very deep houses, then curtains come to play a big role in architecture. - Arne Jacobsen

"I am sure that as a woman I can do a very good skyscraper," she said. "I don't think it is only for men." - Zaha Hadid

I hope that America as a whole, and especially its architects, will become more seriously involved in producing a new architectural culture that would bring the nation to the apex – where it has stood before – and lead the world. - Tadao Ando

The job of buildings is to improve human relations: architecture must ease them, not make them worse. - Ralph Erskine

"People used to think women did not have enough logic. Well, that is absolute nonsense. I don't know the ego of a man, or how their mentality works, but there is no difference at all in capability, not formally in terms of the buildings at least. There might be differences in women's leadership qualities or in their ego issues, but we can design in the same way if we have the chance." - Zaha Hadid

“Several ethnographic surveys of traditional cultures have found that the better a society treats its women, the less it embraces war.” - Pinker, Steven.

Architects in the past have tended to concentrate their attention on the building as a static object. I believe dynamics are more important: the dynamics of people, their interaction with spaces and environmental condition. - John Portman

Architecture is not a private affair; even a house must serve a whole family and its friends, and most buildings are used by everybody, people of all walks of life. If a building is to meet the needs of all the people, the architect must look for some common ground of understanding and experience. - John Portman

Architecture is the work of nations. - John Ruskin

I think the future of architecture does not lie so much in continuing to fill up the landscape as in bringing back life and order to our cities and towns. - Gottfried Boehm

1. Women in Architecture: We Need Them - http://www.archdaily.com/214742/
2. Zaha Hadid talks about gender issue in architecture: http://www.businessinsider.com/zaha-hadid-on-women-in-architecture-2013-2