*Materials will be in Chapter 3. But I finish this chapter first.
Chapter 4 Exterior Forms
Today,
cities are filled with buildings that are competing to be the most eye-catching
structure. The mindset of great buildings symbolizes the growing success of the
country was one of the factors for these dynamic buildings to continue
developing, for instance, the commonly discussed topic was which country has
the title for “The World’s Tallest Building”. Most importantly, exterior form
is the most significant element besides colour and material for users to judge
a building. Previously, it is easy to identify styles due to the established
building form and similar design approach from architects of the same period
such as the Bauhaus style; the form of modern contemporary on the contrary is
rather hard to define (O’Gorman, 1998) due to the reason that minimalism form
with geometrical lines or the conceptual architecture with dynamic structure
are all considered as modern style. Nonetheless, the key point here is to
examine the female user’s positive and negative perception towards these modern
designs that is constantly transforming.
From
previous chapter, some colour and material are easily categorize as feminine
due to the majority of female preference towards it as well as the
characteristic that is associated with female. On the other hand, form together
with the combination of colour and material as well as its function may be
difficult and debatable to distinguish between feminine and masculine building
based on stereotype perception, Therefore, the intention is to focus on
structural form only and the idea is expected to further assist in examining
the research issue.
Architecture is a language of metaphor (O’Gorman,1998). Survey conducted by Menna Agha shows how people see gender qualities in the built environment.* The results indicate the general mindset of gendered architecture in people’s mind. On the whole, curve, organic and simple was defined as feminine form whereas geometrical, angle and complex being masculine form. (Agha, Taw, 2010) A survey was conducted to investigate how female response between the three chosen modern contemporary exterior forms with the scale of 1 as most unwelcoming to 5 as most welcoming. Hypotheses were made that older female as well as lower income and status respond more negatively towards modern geometrical forms.
*Refer to Appendix for details.
| Fig.1 Linear form Fig.2 Curvature form Fig.3 Dynamic form |
Fig. 4 Overall results. With the scale of 1 = most
unwelcoming and 5 = most welcoming.
Based
on the survey result conducted for this project, most female respond positively
towards the curvature exterior form (Fig.2) in which majority picked the scale
of 3, 4 and 5. Psychologists and neuroscientists have stated that human
preference towards curves is mainly because it is hard-wired into the brain.
(Jaffe, 2013) Experts have also
announced that rounded corner is easier for the eye. (Anthony, 2011)* Other
factors could be the similarity of curvy forms to a woman’s physique that
conveys the feminine idea of nurturing to female (Izhaki, 2013). Likewise, the
fact that round organic shapes are well associated with nature emits warmth and
harmony (Adams, 2013) In 1909, psychologist Kate Gordon said, “Curves are in
general felt to be more beautiful than straight lines”. (Adams, 2013)
Fig.5 Seattle Central Library
On the other hand, the dynamic form (Fig. 3) consists of
both positive and negative responses.
Angular design can either be attractive or provocative, depending on
different users. For instance, the mix criticism towards the Seattle Central Library
(Fig.5) by Rem Koolhaas in which some commented as “beautiful” and some
“horrifying”. (Wirednewyork.com, 2003) Sharp angles subconsciously remind us of
knife or claws that is harmful. (Nixon, 2010) Linear form (Fig. 1) received the
most negative responses. Lines and symmetrical shapes portray the masculine
attributes of starkness and formality induced lower preferences.
Fig.6 Responses from
age below 20. Fig.7 Responses from age 21 – 30.
Fig.8 Responses from age
31 - 40. Fig.9 Responses from age 41 – 50.
Fig.10 Responses from age
51 - 60. Fig.11
Responses from age 61 and more.
From the
results, age shows to be one of the fundamental factors that influence the
responses. Young adults with age below 20 and 21 – 30 years old responded that dynamic
exterior form is the most welcoming mainly because they are living in the
future. In this world of technological advancement, the new generation lives in
a world that is more volatile and complex than any previous time. Also, “The
future is feminine, the feminine is more masculine” Young women are rejecting
the traditional role and redefining their feminine role to be in tune with the
changes of the future. (Business Future Network London, 1997) At the age of 31
– 40, working women are often exposed to the surrounding building, hence the
respond were quite neutral for all three forms although that result was showing
curvature and dynamic as the most welcoming. Positive responses for curves and
linear increase and angular form decrease, as women get older. In fact,
majority of women ages 61 and above react negatively towards the dynamic form.
Older generation viewed linear shapes as typicality owing to the fact most of
the everyday objects or buildings are designed in basic shapes (Bar & Neta,
2007), results in familiarity towards the exterior form. A few notable negative
keywords for the angular form were recorded during a short conversation with
several elderly such as “weird, shocking and sharp”. Other important factor for
older age female to prefer sinuous is the traditional mindset for Feng Shui.
Basically, older generation believes that angle or corner means abrupt stoppage
and emits negative energies whereas curve or sphere symbolizes continuous flow,
and therefore harmony and eternity. (Nick, 2003)
Fig.12 Lower education level. Fig.13 Middle education level.
Fig.14 Higher education
level.
Factors
like education level along with social status could also be the factors that
influence the female perception towards the exterior form. Results show that
female with lower education level respond negatively towards the dynamic and
linear form. The high possibility that lower education lead to lack of
confidence and exposure to different architecture structure seeing that the
majority in this category (Fig.12) are female with age 61 and above with no
income. In contrast, female with middle education level feel most comfortable
towards dynamite form. At this level, the group (Fig.13) is likely to be or
have been university or college students hence, they feel prefer trendy with
the latest technology and high exposure towards the Internet. Eventually,
higher education shows more positive responses towards all three forms,
especially linear form compared to low and middle education level. Female in
this group are mainly women with high-income status that are confident and have
a more open-minded thinking.
In a nutshell, the exterior architecture
gives the first impression that triggers the desire to enter a building. Female
negative and positive responses for exterior form or facade are particularly
important, as women are now also the equal primary users together with men.
Although the hypothesis was achieved but due to the difficulties in finding the
balance numbers for all age group in each education level which in some measure
could affect the accuracy of the results. Nonetheless, female high preference
for sinuous shapes compare to linear and dynamic form is important to taken
into design consideration. Future studies could look into other factors such as
period trends, fashion, culture and others. (Bar & Neta, 2005) Furthermore,
the issue of imbalance gender in the field of architecture is also important to
take note whereby the design approach between men and women has always been
very different. Clearly, modern designs are moving more towards masculine
traits in terms of functionality and aesthetic value. Marika Shioiri-Clark and
John Cary noted in an article for CNN, “It is not a question of whether, but to
what extent, buildings are less beautiful, less functional, less equitable
because women are not creating them.” Architecture is becoming no longer just a
shelter but artworks to be appreciated by people.
*Slight changes on the last part. However, I'm still not confirm with it yet.
Thanks for reading.
*Slight changes on the last part. However, I'm still not confirm with it yet.
Thanks for reading.




























